Cast Irons Vs Forged – What’s Better And For Who?
Are you new to golf and wondering about the different types of irons available? One of the most common questions asked by beginner golfers is whether they should choose Cast Irons vs Forged Irons. In this article, we will break down the differences between these two types of irons and help you make an informed decision about which is right for you.
What Are Cast Irons?
Cast irons are made by pouring molten metal into a mold. The metal used in cast irons is typically a combination of steel, carbon, and other alloys. The mold is then heated to a high temperature to create a solid iron head. The process of casting irons allows manufacturers to create a consistent and uniform shape for each clubhead.
What Are Forged Irons?
Forged irons, on the other hand, are made by pounding a piece of metal into shape using a hammer or press. The metal used in forged irons is typically softer and more malleable than the metal used in cast irons. This allows manufacturers to shape the metal into more intricate designs and create a more organic feel in the clubhead.
Cast Irons Vs Forged Irons
Cast irons and forged irons each have their own unique characteristics that make them suitable for different types of golfers. Cast irons tend to be more forgiving and easier to hit, while forged irons offer more control and workability. In general, cast irons are favored by beginners and high handicappers, while forged irons are preferred by low handicappers and professionals.
Advantages Of Cast Irons
One of the main advantages of cast irons is their forgiveness. Because the clubheads are created using a consistent mold, each club in a set will have the same weight and shape. This consistency makes it easier for golfers to hit the ball consistently and reduces the chance of mishits.
Another advantage of cast irons is their affordability. Because the manufacturing process is less labor-intensive than forging, cast irons tend to be less expensive than their forged counterparts.
Disadvantages Of Cast Irons
While cast irons offer forgiveness and affordability, they do have some disadvantages. One of the main drawbacks of cast irons is their lack of workability. Because the clubheads are created using a consistent mold, there is less room for customization and shaping. This can be a disadvantage for golfers who prefer to shape their shots and work the ball around the course.
Who Should Be Using Cast Irons And Why?
Cast irons are best suited for beginners and high handicappers who are looking for forgiveness and consistency in their shots. If you are new to golf or struggle with mishits, cast irons may be a good option for you. They are also a good choice for golfers who are on a budget and looking for an affordable set of clubs.
Advantages Of Forged Irons
One of the main advantages of forged irons is their workability. Because the clubheads are shaped using a hammer or press, manufacturers can create more intricate designs and customizations. This allows golfers to shape their shots and have more control over their ball flight.
Forged irons also tend to offer a better feel and feedback than cast irons. The softer metal used in forging creates a more organic and responsive feel, which can be important for golfers who prioritize feel and control.
Disadvantages Of Forged Irons
While forged irons offer more control and workability, they do have some drawbacks. One of the main disadvantages of forged irons is their price. Because the manufacturing process is more labor-intensive than casting, forged irons tend to be more expensive.
Who Should Be Using Forged Irons And Why?
Forged irons are best suited for low handicappers and professionals who are looking for more control and workability in their shots. If you are an experienced golfer who values precision and control, forged irons may be a good option for you. They are also a good choice for golfers who prioritize feel and feedback in their shots.
Cast Irons | Forged Irons | |
|---|---|---|
| Pros | – Forgiving and consistent | – More control and workability |
| – Affordable | – Better feel and feedback | |
| – More customization options | ||
| Cons | – Less workability and shaping options | – More expensive |
| – Less forgiving and consistent than cast irons | ||
| Recommended | Beginners and high handicappers | Low handicappers and professionals |
| Golfers on a budget | Golfers who prioritize feel and feedback | |
| Golfers who want more control over their ball flight | ||
| Examples | Callaway Rogue | Mizuno MP-20 |
| TaylorMade SIM MAX | Titleist 620 MB | |
| Ping G425 | Srixon Z785 |
Cast Irons Vs Forged: Price?
As mentioned earlier, cast irons tend to be less expensive than forged irons due to the less labor-intensive manufacturing process. A set of cast irons can range from a few hundred dollars to around a thousand dollars, depending on the brand and model.
Forged irons, on the other hand, tend to be more expensive due to the more intricate manufacturing process. A set of forged irons can range from around a thousand dollars to several thousand dollars, depending on the brand and model.
Cast Irons Vs Forged: Durability?
Both cast and forged irons are durable and can last for many years if taken care of properly. However, some golfers argue that forged irons are more durable due to the softer metal used in the manufacturing process. This softer metal can absorb shock better than the harder metal used in cast irons, which can lead to fewer cracks or other damage over time.
Cast Irons Vs Forged: Distance?
In terms of distance, there is no clear winner between cast and forged irons. Both types of irons can provide excellent distance, depending on the golfer’s swing and the specific clubhead design.
Cast Irons Vs Forged Irons: Workability, Feel & Control?
When it comes to workability, feel, and control, forged irons tend to have the edge over cast irons. The softer metal used in forging allows for more customization and shaping, which can be important for golfers who want to shape their shots and have more control over their ball flight. Additionally, the softer metal used in forging provides a more responsive and organic feel, which can be important for golfers who prioritize feel and feedback.
Which is Better Cast or Forged Irons?
The answer to this question depends on the individual golfer’s skill level, preferences, and budget. Cast irons tend to be more forgiving and easier to hit, making them a good choice for beginners and high handicappers. Forged irons offer more control and workability, making them a good choice for low handicappers and professionals.
Should All High Handicappers Use Cast Irons?
While cast irons are a good choice for high handicappers, they are not the only option. Some high handicappers may prefer the feel and workability of forged irons, while others may benefit from a hybrid set that combines both cast and forged irons.
Should All Low Handicappers Use Forged Irons?
While forged irons are a good choice for low handicappers, they are not the only option. Some low handicappers may prefer the forgiveness and consistency of cast irons, while others may benefit from a set that combines both cast and forged irons.
Can High Handicappers Use Forged Irons?
Yes, high handicappers can use forged irons. However, they may find them more difficult to hit than cast irons due to the increased workability and control.
Are All Cast Irons Game Improvement?
While many cast irons are designed with game improvement in mind, not all cast irons are created equal. Some cast irons are designed for more advanced golfers and offer more workability and control than others.
Are All Forged Irons Players Irons?
While many forged irons are marketed as “players” irons, not all forged irons are exclusively designed for low handicappers and professionals. Some forged irons are designed with game improvement in mind and offer a blend of forgiveness and workability.
Are Cast Irons Getting Better For Feel And Workability?
As technology improves, cast irons are getting better for feel and workability. Some manufacturers are using advanced materials and design techniques to create cast irons that offer more customization and shaping options.
Are Forged Irons Becoming More Forgiving?
As technology improves, forged irons are becoming more forgiving. Some manufacturers are using advanced materials and design techniques to create forged irons that offer more forgiveness and consistency.
Do All Pros Use Forged Irons?
While many pros prefer forged irons, not all pros use them exclusively. Some pros use a combination of cast and forged irons, depending on the specific shot and situation.
Forged Irons Vs Blades
Blades are a specific type of forged iron that is designed for the most skilled and precise golfers. Blades are typically small and have a narrow sweet spot, making them difficult to hit consistently. While some low handicappers and professionals prefer blades for their workability and control, they are not recommended for beginners or high handicappers.
The Best Cast Irons
One of our favorite cast iron sets is the Callaway Rogue set. The Rogue irons offer excellent forgiveness and consistency, making them a good choice for beginners and high handicappers. Some pros of the Rogue irons include their affordability and ease of use. Some cons include their lack of workability and feel compared to forged irons.
The Best Forged Irons
One of our favorite forged iron sets is the Mizuno MP-20 set. The MP-20 irons offer excellent feel and workability, making them a good choice for low handicappers and professionals. Some pros of the MP-20 irons include their excellent feel and feedback, as well as their customization options. Some cons include their high price point and lack of forgiveness compared to cast irons.
Overall Conclusion
Cast irons and forged irons each have their own unique characteristics and advantages. The decision of which type of iron to use ultimately depends on the individual golfer’s skill level, preferences, and budget. Cast irons tend to be more forgiving and affordable, while forged irons offer more control and workability. By understanding the differences between these two types of irons, you can make an informed decision about which is right for you.
In conclusion, the decision between cast irons and forged irons ultimately comes down to personal preference and skill level. Beginners and high handicappers may benefit from the forgiveness and consistency of cast irons, while low handicappers and professionals may prefer the workability and control of forged irons. It is also worth considering hybrid sets that combine both cast and forged irons to get the best of both worlds. When shopping for irons, it is important to try out different sets and consult with a professional to find the right fit for you. With the right set of irons, you can improve your game and enjoy playing golf even more.
If you’re ready to take your game to the next level why not check out our guides to the best drivers, or Wedges or putt for dough with our list of the best putters. Fun Golf is all about putting the fun back into your game, let us be your guide for all you need to know about golf. Also if our game’s not up to scratch maybe think about the golf balls you use, our guide to the best golf balls is worth a read.
